Lake Superior Magazine

Lake Superior Journal
by James R. Marshall


Jim Marshall

The Promise of the Americas

 

In 1965, we became the brand new and proud owners of the sunken vessel America and of the seasoned 38-foot Peterson cruiser Skipper Sam.

We acquired both through a deal with hardhat diver Paul J. Flynn, whose father had claim on America. With the help of then-congressman, John Blatnik, we quickly gained a salvage permit from the National Park Service in the fall of 1965.

Since June 7, 1928, America lay where it foundered in the waters off Isle Royale, Michigan. We wanted to salvage and refloat it. 

Saving a sunken vessel begins with a very large dose of optimism. As many of you loyal readers well know, the salvage plan almost worked, but two divers with explosives sealed America’s demise in April 1966. 

They blew a new hole in its hull, and the Isle Royale National Park superintendent saw no reason to permit World War III to begin in his national park.

Since that disappointment, there has been the fun of seeing many divers preserve this highly “diveable” wreck, entombed in fresh water and some of it less than two feet below the surface. But as we contemplate the remains of this 180-foot vessel built in 1903, we must not lose sight of what it meant to the people who used it and waited for it. Boats and ships are often so much more than the sum of their engines and hulls. 

America, the vessel, and America, the country, gave great promise to the folks who carved an existence from the formidable northern shore of Lake Superior. They came here at the turn of the century - yes, that one - 102 years ago. Many lived in Norway or Sweden, where unless they inherited land, they faced the future of a working servant. Land stayed within families; sales almost never went beyond family members.

The story of America - the country - had persisted for several years with legends claiming that “you can own land by simply settling on it.” Now I ask you - might this promise of “land you can own” have encouraged travel to this New World? Boy, did it!

The America at Tofte by Howard Sivertson
America held the promise of goods arriving and of fish catches selling for the settlers of Lake Superior’s Minnesota shore, as captured by painter Howard Sivertson in this image from his book Schooners, Skiffs and Steamships, Stories along Lake Superior’s Water Trails.

They arrived off the trans-Atlantic ships in droves, usually financially limited, often staring at signs in a language they didn’t understand. In today’s world, we accept that many people are familiar with our language, but in those days, English was more rare. As the copper mines and other eastern endeavors grew, more workers were desperately needed. Settlers who sought Lake Superior resisted the opportunity visible on the East Coast for the promise of “land like Norway” along Lake Superior. 

It wasn’t easy, but it happened! With land titles in hand, home construction began, and fish houses and docks quickly followed. Relatively simple open boats were built and men went out to net fish. Now they sorely needed supplies.

Booth Fisheries had the muscle. After years of hit-and-miss fish buying, they sensed the time had come. The vessel America was brought into service on western Lake Superior, routinely making dozens of calls on fishermen - each way - along the shore between Duluth and Fort William (now Thunder Bay) in Ontario. 

Descendants of those first shore settlers recall the magic of the steamer America’s name, vividly introducing another promise of “America” to the immigrants. 

For years, Booth maintained four vessels buying fish on Lake Superior. The vessels, including America, brought goods to the fishing families or provided transportation to the larger cities.

America’s dream of a growing positive population might be best demonstrated here on Lake Superior. Families came and settled, finally conveying their satisfaction to those still in Europe. More families followed.

These families overcame the barriers of languages and the challenges of earning a living on a sometimes unforgiving and powerful lake. But look at the end result: a rich Lake Superior culture survived, prospered and, in oh so many ways, fulfilled its promises.

LSM
A selection of Jim Marshall’s columns of lake lore and his inland sea voyages has been published as Lake Superior Journal: Views from the Bridge by Lake Superior Port Cities Inc. Follow this link for more information.
Feedback: jrm@lakesuperior.com



Return to Table of Contents