Lake Superior Journal

by Bob Mackreth

Traces in the Forest
A Flexible Flyer Evokes Christmases Past

Bob MackrethI found a child’s sled once, discarded in the forest near an abandoned cottage on an island in Lake Superior.

Not so much a sled, actually, as the remains of a sled. I was hiking with a friend, and no longer remember which one of us first noticed the odd angles of curved metal entwined in the roots of a tree.

We examined the puzzling object, then suddenly understood: This was an old Flexible Flyer, tossed aside decades ago. The wooden portions had long since rotted, leaving the steel frame and runners to remind us that children once lived on this island, shouting, playing and exclaiming with delight at the sight of presents beneath another kind of tree, a Christmas tree.

There was no doubt in my mind that the sled had found its way to the island as a Christmas present. The fishermen-farmers of the Apostle Islands lived well enough on the bounty of the lake and the fruits of their labor, but cash money was always scarce. A store-bought sled would have been a major purchase, to be considered carefully. What other occasion besides Christmas would warrant such a magnificent gift?

Travel by dog sled on the Apostle Islands
On snowshoes, by dog sleds (this and photo below) and even with children’s toy sleds, residents of the Apostle Islands have long found ways to survive and thrive in winter.  Photo Wisconsin Historical Society

All the Apostle Islands, save Madeline, are deserted now at Christmas, but that was not always so. Just as traders and trappers once marked the day with “Joyeux Noël” at La Pointe, pioneer farmers surely offered wishes of “Merry Christmas” on Sand and Basswood islands, and Norwegian-born fishermen greeted each other with, “God Jul!”

When and where was Christmas first observed in the Chequamegon region? It’s hard to say. Did the fur traders Radisson and des Groseilliers even keep track of the calendar in their rude lakeside cabin in 1659? If they did not, surely the intrepid Jesuit, Claude Allouez, marked the occasion six years later at his mission near the mouth of Fish Creek.

No records tell us how Father Allouez observed Christmas, but perhaps he followed the example of his missionary colleague, Jean de Brébeuf, who preached on the shores of Lake Huron a few years earlier. Eager to recount the Savior’s birth in terms his Indian listeners would understand, he told of a child wrapped in rabbit fur rather than linen and sleeping not in a manger, but on a bed of birch bark. Hunters, not shepherds, knelt before him, and three great chiefs brought gifts of pelts for the Babe. After preaching, Father Brébeuf led his congregation in a carol he composed in their own Huron language, Jesous Ahatonnia: “Jesus Is Born.”

Dog sled on Apostle Islands
Photo Hamilton Nelson Ross / Wisconsin Historical Society

Years would pass before we can find clear, written reference to a Christmas observance among the Apostle Islands. Long after Madeline Island had passed from French hands, well after Stars and Stripes replaced the Union Jack over its trading post, another renowned missionary made his way to La Pointe: Father Frederic Baraga, the famed Snowshoe Priest. Arriving in July, the energetic Slovenian cleric set to work, building a chapel and teaching himself the Ojibway language. His hard work was rewarded in the way he considered most important: On his first island Christmas, Father Baraga celebrated by baptizing 22 new converts.

By the late 1800s, a new culture added its customs to the islands’ holiday mix. Among the cherished traditions of the Norwegian immigrants in the little village on Sand Island was the Feast of St. Lucia, the “Queen of Lights,” 12 days before Christmas. In the old country, young girls would dress in white and carry candles from house to house to dispel the winter gloom. Today, spotting the foundations of fishermen’s cottages, it is easy to imagine their daughters preserving the ritual as the waves of the lake roared an accompaniment.

Soon, though, the islanders adopted new customs. The Christmas tree was not yet common in Norway, but the German tradition was already established in America. In January 1911, the Bayfield Press noted: “Louis Moe came in from Sand Island last Friday. He says an especially pleasant Christmas was enjoyed by the residents on the island, and that a large Christmas tree in the schoolhouse was a pleasant event attended by 56 people. A fine chicken supper was served by the Ladies Aid Society.”

The remains of that schoolhouse are easy to find, but no one celebrates Christmas on Sand Island anymore; the last year-round residents moved in the 1940s. The farms of Basswood Island are fading into forest, and even the restored fishing camp on Manitou Island, where hard-working men once passed lonely winters, has been shuttered by the National Park Service. Yet, on the beaches and trails of the Apostle Islands, and deep in the woods where a child’s sled has slowly become one with the forest, the ghosts of Christmas past remain.

This issue’s Journal writer:
Historian-writer Bob Mackreth lives in northern Wisconsin with his wife and four Newfoundland dogs. With more than 30 years as a park ranger, he takes special interest in National Park Service issues and history of the Great Lakes.


Feedback: edit@lakesuperior.com 
Return to Table of Contents
Subscribe to Lake Superior Magazine